Dear Voice,
I thank you for your comments and views on the subject matter. However, personal issues and emotions should be left at the door to ensure a healthy discussion. This topic needs to be discussed and addressed objectively.
Firstly, it is worth noting that there are many different segments of society having differing points of views on the subject matter. From professionals in the urban city to the folks in the “kampung’s” all have a say about it. Even members of the same segment have differing opinions. For example, there is the so called “Malay ultra” group that feel that this country is theirs and everybody else is “sekadar menumpang”. Many young professionals feel that NEP has not helped enough Malays. There is also the corporate/business group that feel that NEP has made it more difficult to do business. Not to forget the group that wants the NEP to be put aside and allow equality to take place. There is also a group that feels that if you take away the NEP you must also take away vernacular schools.
As you can see, there are so many views and so many segments to manage and as Ahmad Ariff mentioned, what matters at the end of the day is convincing 51% of the voters to vote for your party and in my case BN. The government of the day cannot just look and favour one particular segment or group of a society; it needs to implement policies that are acceptable to the majority of the people.
You may have noticed that Gerakkan has showed positive signs of leaving BN. MCA leaders in a recent interview mentioned that leaving BN if UMNO does not change is an option. If UMNO and the Malays continue to be stubborn (which is an option) then it will spell the demise of BN. It is because of the arrogance and chauvinistic attitude portrayed by Malay leaders that caused BN lose badly in the recent March 08 elections. This mind set needs to change and we need to come out of our comfort zone. We need to take cognisance that we are not just leading one race but all races. If we continue with this attitude then BN will surely loose in the next election.
As I mentioned in my previous article, even with the NEP the Bumi’s only own 17% of the economic pie. Something must be seriously wrong with our policy. The NEP has been in existence for 30 years and we cannot even achieve the 30% target? What is the point of having a policy that does not achieve its objective?
I am not against the NEP but I do however think that there should be a specific mechanism and timeline to achieve the desired results. The NEP is not a god given right for the Malays. We did not have it before we achieved independence nor was it implemented immediately after independence. It was only implemented after the 1969 riots to correct the economic imbalance at that point in time. The NEP was subsequently replaced by the NDP in 1990. Even ex-prime minister Tun Mahathir once said that the NEP should be abolished at one point but the time is not now.
All I am saying is take a look at the policy again and find out what’s working and what’s not. Insanity is defined as doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result. It is time to do things differently.
Sunday, October 5, 2008
Thursday, September 11, 2008
Merdeka!!! Continued….
Readers are advised to read the original Merdeka article below before reading this article.
It was a little bit disheartening at first when no one gave any comments to my Merdeka Article.
Was it old news? Boring? Or didn’t people care anymore? It is none of the above actually.
In light of the most recent, controversial and racist remark made by the now famous Mr. Ahmad, comments came in through emails, sms and even phone calls. I would like to acknowledge readers and those who shared their views on the subject matter. I guess it is easier and safer to talk about these sensitive issues in private to avoid going behind bars.
As bizarre as it sounds, I will attempt to write about racial disintegration in the hope of achieving racial integration. The main issue at hand is the NEP/DEB where non-Malays feel that it is an unfair policy whilst the majority of the Malays feel that it is god given right policy. I have said before that there is a clear mismatch of expectations between the races in Malaysia and to prove my point further read the very contrasting and differing point of views shared by many Malaysians:
1. On History
Non-Malays
Malaysia is not owned by the Malays to begin with. Just like the Non-Malays the Malays came from other parts of the world, came to Malaya and called it their home. Therefore the Malays are also originally foreign to this land. The real Bumiputra’s of this country are the orang asli’s.
Malays
This country is historically owned by Malays and even the British acknowledge this. In recognition of the Sultans rule, the British signed treaties with the Malay Rulers and not with the other races. Further proof is that Malaysia was previously known as Tanah Melayu & Malaya.
2. On the Economy
Non-Malays
This country developed and flourished economically because of the hard work of non-Malays. The non-Malays are the fabric of this nation that allows this country to propel forward. They had to struggle, study and work hard to earn a living in this country. If it wasn’t for the Non Malays the Bumiputra’s would be living in jungles and trees. The Malays have it all easy with the support of the government and NEP.
Malays
The Non-Malays have a culture that is aligned to earthly success. They have a civilization that survived the test of time. Malays on the other hand have just started moving forward 60 years ago therefore requiring more time to succeed. It was the British that brought in foreigners into this country. The Malays never invited them into the country.As a race they made many sacrifices such as changing this country’s name from Tanah Melayu to Malaya to Malaysia. This is to help other races feel part of this country. Even the Bahasa Jawi was shelved for the same reason.
3. NEP
Non-Malays
The NEP has failed to accomplish what it was set out to do. I.e. to ensure that the country achieves some balance in terms of economic distribution. Instead, it has only benefited a small no of bumiputra’s. Contracts are only given to a selected few.
Malays
The NEP has benefited the Malays in many ways. Based on the stats, there are now more Malay Doctors, Lawyers, Engineers, Architects and Businessmen than there was 30 years ago.
4. On Competitiveness
Non-Malays
Non-Malays are not willing to employ Malays because they are slow and not competitive. The NEP is the reason why Malays are not competitive. It has served as an ineffective crutch that cripples the Malays.
Malays
Malays have different values then the non Malays. The non Malays only think of Money while the Malays believe that there is more to life than money.
5 On Opportunities
Non-Malays
There should be equal opportunities for every Malaysian no matter the race. It is a human rights issue. There should be equal opportunities in terms of education and contracts distribution.
Malays
The Non-Malays are impatient and greedy. Even after owning more than 80% of the economic cake they demand for more and more.
.....................................................................................................................................................................
I personally feel embarrassed (not in an arrogant way) that the Malays have to ask for extra help in order to be competitive. As a Malay, I am not proud that after 50 years of independence Malays are still struggling to stem a mark in the economic pie. Even with the NEP the Bumi’s only own 17% of the economic pie. Just have a look at newly developed housing areas, how many Malays actually own a piece of the action? How many Malays own luxury homes? How many Malays own a bungalow or a semi-d home? Everywhere you look property is owned by non Malays. The majority of the Malays own property in some kampong which is negligible in value in comparison to the market value of properties in the city.
I would be lying if I said that I did not benefit from the NEP. In fact no successful Malay can claim that he or she did not benefit from the NEP. It would be selfish of me to say that we should wipe out the NEP policy totally when I know for a fact that there are many Malays that still need support and help. If the wealth of the nation is not distributed fairly and equally I fear that there will be more tension amongst the races.
Having said that, it would be totally unfair for the NEP to be in existence forever. The government should have a specific target date to achieve the desired results. Non Malays who are in need should also be helped.
I obviously don’t have all the answers but I hope this article will help Malaysian’s understand each other a little bit better.
It was a little bit disheartening at first when no one gave any comments to my Merdeka Article.
Was it old news? Boring? Or didn’t people care anymore? It is none of the above actually.
In light of the most recent, controversial and racist remark made by the now famous Mr. Ahmad, comments came in through emails, sms and even phone calls. I would like to acknowledge readers and those who shared their views on the subject matter. I guess it is easier and safer to talk about these sensitive issues in private to avoid going behind bars.
As bizarre as it sounds, I will attempt to write about racial disintegration in the hope of achieving racial integration. The main issue at hand is the NEP/DEB where non-Malays feel that it is an unfair policy whilst the majority of the Malays feel that it is god given right policy. I have said before that there is a clear mismatch of expectations between the races in Malaysia and to prove my point further read the very contrasting and differing point of views shared by many Malaysians:
1. On History
Non-Malays
Malaysia is not owned by the Malays to begin with. Just like the Non-Malays the Malays came from other parts of the world, came to Malaya and called it their home. Therefore the Malays are also originally foreign to this land. The real Bumiputra’s of this country are the orang asli’s.
Malays
This country is historically owned by Malays and even the British acknowledge this. In recognition of the Sultans rule, the British signed treaties with the Malay Rulers and not with the other races. Further proof is that Malaysia was previously known as Tanah Melayu & Malaya.
2. On the Economy
Non-Malays
This country developed and flourished economically because of the hard work of non-Malays. The non-Malays are the fabric of this nation that allows this country to propel forward. They had to struggle, study and work hard to earn a living in this country. If it wasn’t for the Non Malays the Bumiputra’s would be living in jungles and trees. The Malays have it all easy with the support of the government and NEP.
Malays
The Non-Malays have a culture that is aligned to earthly success. They have a civilization that survived the test of time. Malays on the other hand have just started moving forward 60 years ago therefore requiring more time to succeed. It was the British that brought in foreigners into this country. The Malays never invited them into the country.As a race they made many sacrifices such as changing this country’s name from Tanah Melayu to Malaya to Malaysia. This is to help other races feel part of this country. Even the Bahasa Jawi was shelved for the same reason.
3. NEP
Non-Malays
The NEP has failed to accomplish what it was set out to do. I.e. to ensure that the country achieves some balance in terms of economic distribution. Instead, it has only benefited a small no of bumiputra’s. Contracts are only given to a selected few.
Malays
The NEP has benefited the Malays in many ways. Based on the stats, there are now more Malay Doctors, Lawyers, Engineers, Architects and Businessmen than there was 30 years ago.
4. On Competitiveness
Non-Malays
Non-Malays are not willing to employ Malays because they are slow and not competitive. The NEP is the reason why Malays are not competitive. It has served as an ineffective crutch that cripples the Malays.
Malays
Malays have different values then the non Malays. The non Malays only think of Money while the Malays believe that there is more to life than money.
5 On Opportunities
Non-Malays
There should be equal opportunities for every Malaysian no matter the race. It is a human rights issue. There should be equal opportunities in terms of education and contracts distribution.
Malays
The Non-Malays are impatient and greedy. Even after owning more than 80% of the economic cake they demand for more and more.
.....................................................................................................................................................................
I personally feel embarrassed (not in an arrogant way) that the Malays have to ask for extra help in order to be competitive. As a Malay, I am not proud that after 50 years of independence Malays are still struggling to stem a mark in the economic pie. Even with the NEP the Bumi’s only own 17% of the economic pie. Just have a look at newly developed housing areas, how many Malays actually own a piece of the action? How many Malays own luxury homes? How many Malays own a bungalow or a semi-d home? Everywhere you look property is owned by non Malays. The majority of the Malays own property in some kampong which is negligible in value in comparison to the market value of properties in the city.
I would be lying if I said that I did not benefit from the NEP. In fact no successful Malay can claim that he or she did not benefit from the NEP. It would be selfish of me to say that we should wipe out the NEP policy totally when I know for a fact that there are many Malays that still need support and help. If the wealth of the nation is not distributed fairly and equally I fear that there will be more tension amongst the races.
Having said that, it would be totally unfair for the NEP to be in existence forever. The government should have a specific target date to achieve the desired results. Non Malays who are in need should also be helped.
I obviously don’t have all the answers but I hope this article will help Malaysian’s understand each other a little bit better.
Monday, September 1, 2008
Merdeka???
Merdeka! Merdeka! Merdeka!
The spirit and feeling of this years Merdeka celebration is not quite the same as the celebrations before this. This year we celebrate Merdeka with some tension rising. We cannot hide or sweep under the carpet what is actually brewing in the hearts and minds of the younger generation no matter the race.
The racial tension is worsening by the day. People cursing at each other, making fun of their own national anthem, questioning their rights and rights of others etc. I can only imagine what it will look like ten years down the road if something is not done now and I am not just talking about the muhibah spirit and rhetoric speeches. Thanks to the wise management of our leaders today (sweep everything under the carpet policy) we will have an uphill task in managing racial problems in the years to come.
I grew up in Penang and studied at a National Primary and Secondary School. There I mixed and befriended everyone and anyone no matter the race. It was great and I had a lot of fun. Even when I was working in Penang, I did not feel like a social outcast even though majority of my colleagues were non Malays. Hanging out at coffee bean and mamak stalls with my friends no matter the race on a weekly basis was a norm for me back then.
Things however changed in 2002 when I moved to work in KL. It was as if I moved to another country. I suddenly felt that everyone was cold and I could feel the racial tension in the air. I resented that feeling. Call me naive but I then finally realized that many if not majority of the people in KL are racist and are only interested in protecting their own neck and race.
The racial tension in KL and most parts of the country is bad. I have received direct feedback from my non Malay friends that the reason they do not hire Malays is because they are slow and inefficient. My Malay friends on the other hand say that the Chinese are greedy and everything just boils down to money. After speaking to my Malay, Chinese and Indian friends I have come up with the following conclusion about their views, opinions and frustrations.
1. The Malays are upset with the non Malays for questioning their special rights.
2. The Chinese and Indians resent the Malays for treating them like second class citizens and not allowing equal opportunities.
Rightly or wrongly, there is clearly a mismatch of expectation. To be continued……
The spirit and feeling of this years Merdeka celebration is not quite the same as the celebrations before this. This year we celebrate Merdeka with some tension rising. We cannot hide or sweep under the carpet what is actually brewing in the hearts and minds of the younger generation no matter the race.
The racial tension is worsening by the day. People cursing at each other, making fun of their own national anthem, questioning their rights and rights of others etc. I can only imagine what it will look like ten years down the road if something is not done now and I am not just talking about the muhibah spirit and rhetoric speeches. Thanks to the wise management of our leaders today (sweep everything under the carpet policy) we will have an uphill task in managing racial problems in the years to come.
I grew up in Penang and studied at a National Primary and Secondary School. There I mixed and befriended everyone and anyone no matter the race. It was great and I had a lot of fun. Even when I was working in Penang, I did not feel like a social outcast even though majority of my colleagues were non Malays. Hanging out at coffee bean and mamak stalls with my friends no matter the race on a weekly basis was a norm for me back then.
Things however changed in 2002 when I moved to work in KL. It was as if I moved to another country. I suddenly felt that everyone was cold and I could feel the racial tension in the air. I resented that feeling. Call me naive but I then finally realized that many if not majority of the people in KL are racist and are only interested in protecting their own neck and race.
The racial tension in KL and most parts of the country is bad. I have received direct feedback from my non Malay friends that the reason they do not hire Malays is because they are slow and inefficient. My Malay friends on the other hand say that the Chinese are greedy and everything just boils down to money. After speaking to my Malay, Chinese and Indian friends I have come up with the following conclusion about their views, opinions and frustrations.
1. The Malays are upset with the non Malays for questioning their special rights.
2. The Chinese and Indians resent the Malays for treating them like second class citizens and not allowing equal opportunities.
Rightly or wrongly, there is clearly a mismatch of expectation. To be continued……
Wednesday, August 27, 2008
NOMINATION DAY
August 16, 2008. Permatang Pauh. My friends and I woke up to a very exciting morning as it was nomination day in Permatang Pauh. We had early breakfast and made our way to the nomination centre.
The road was pretty clear but as we got closer to the nomination centre the traffic started to pile up. There were hundreds of PKR supporters in their cars heading towards the same destination. As we got closer to the centre we came across a few hundred PKR supporters that were walking towards the centre. Nothing happened initially until one of them started to shout and jeer at us. They started to knock our doors and hit the windows of our car. We paid no attention to them and kept on driving to avoid any mishaps. I was however pist at that point and wondered why our people were turning into hooligans. Would they be so brave if they did not have the numbers on their side?
Due to the heavy traffic and road blocks everywhere, we had to park our car approximately 2km away from the centre and continued walking from there. As I approached the field of the nomination centre more and more PKR supporters were shouting and screaming as if their daughters had been raped. Majority of them were angry and bitter. Again I paid no attention to them and continued walking.
All candidates contesting must submit their registration form between 9am to 10am. They were also allowed to protest on their opponents between 10am to 11am. The SPR will then check the protest from 11am to 12pm. So, all the supporters of both BN and PKR waited from 9am to 12noon. The 5,000 BN supporters were clearly out numbered by the presence of 20,000 PKR supporters.
Once the nomination process was completed and both candidates acknowledged their supporters the crowd started to disperse. As we were walking towards our car it started to rain heavily. Walking in the rain soaking wet, I said to myself “Thank god it is raining. At least this will help cool down the PKR supporters.” I was dead wrong. They waited for the BN supporters at the end of the road chanting and cursing at us. They were clearly going all out to scare us and therefore win the phsy war on that day.
As a BN supporter I respect all other opposition parties and supporters for their beliefs and stand. I have also experienced many elections but I would have to say that this was the worst in terms of discipline and respect for others. My hope is that such brutal and savage behavior is not practiced in future elections. Let us continue to respect one another no matter what our beliefs and differences maybe.
The road was pretty clear but as we got closer to the nomination centre the traffic started to pile up. There were hundreds of PKR supporters in their cars heading towards the same destination. As we got closer to the centre we came across a few hundred PKR supporters that were walking towards the centre. Nothing happened initially until one of them started to shout and jeer at us. They started to knock our doors and hit the windows of our car. We paid no attention to them and kept on driving to avoid any mishaps. I was however pist at that point and wondered why our people were turning into hooligans. Would they be so brave if they did not have the numbers on their side?
Due to the heavy traffic and road blocks everywhere, we had to park our car approximately 2km away from the centre and continued walking from there. As I approached the field of the nomination centre more and more PKR supporters were shouting and screaming as if their daughters had been raped. Majority of them were angry and bitter. Again I paid no attention to them and continued walking.
All candidates contesting must submit their registration form between 9am to 10am. They were also allowed to protest on their opponents between 10am to 11am. The SPR will then check the protest from 11am to 12pm. So, all the supporters of both BN and PKR waited from 9am to 12noon. The 5,000 BN supporters were clearly out numbered by the presence of 20,000 PKR supporters.
Once the nomination process was completed and both candidates acknowledged their supporters the crowd started to disperse. As we were walking towards our car it started to rain heavily. Walking in the rain soaking wet, I said to myself “Thank god it is raining. At least this will help cool down the PKR supporters.” I was dead wrong. They waited for the BN supporters at the end of the road chanting and cursing at us. They were clearly going all out to scare us and therefore win the phsy war on that day.
As a BN supporter I respect all other opposition parties and supporters for their beliefs and stand. I have also experienced many elections but I would have to say that this was the worst in terms of discipline and respect for others. My hope is that such brutal and savage behavior is not practiced in future elections. Let us continue to respect one another no matter what our beliefs and differences maybe.
Friday, July 25, 2008
The UMNO Saga
I have slept an average of 4 hours a day, spent 2 days a week with my family and not spent enough time at the office this past one month. Why? Because, I am contesting for the UMNO Deputy Youth Chief in Sembrong, Johor.
I never thought that it would be so taxing and difficult. There are 49 branches in my division and I need to get 51% of the votes to be elected as Deputy Youth Chief in Sembrong. I obviously want a strong mandate and therefore would have to work extra hard to get the votes in.
For many, they ask and wonder why on earth am I killing myself spending all that valuable time in politics? Why politics? I think it is the same reason why people represent their country in a certain sport, or why a mother gives her child a 100% devotion. Passion. I have always had passion for politics for some reason. It is like a calling that I cannot resist and I would not be satisfied if I did not do something to address that calling.
I am lucky to have a wife that understands my passion. My son however is still adjusting to the fact that I am always in Johor. He misses me tremendously and keeps telling my wife that he too wants to work with me in Johor. Sadly, politics is no place for a child. The hours and traveling is brutal for a young toddler and besides he has got kindergarten to attend.
My late mother Hanim Hussein use to discourage me from entering politics because of the corruption, back stabbing, greed and dirt that comes as a package in politics. However, she slowly changed her mind when she saw that I was persistent and I kept holding on to my intentions of why i was entering the political arena.
I still believe in the idealisms and struggles of Dato’ Onn, The Tunku, Tun Razak and Tun Hussein. These leaders before us were in politics purely to serve the people. These days it is quite the opposite but I believe it is not too late to change.
I am sure that many young Malaysians share the same idealisms that I hold on to so dearly. I pray and hope that we do not forget our intentions and not get swayed along the way.
I never thought that it would be so taxing and difficult. There are 49 branches in my division and I need to get 51% of the votes to be elected as Deputy Youth Chief in Sembrong. I obviously want a strong mandate and therefore would have to work extra hard to get the votes in.
For many, they ask and wonder why on earth am I killing myself spending all that valuable time in politics? Why politics? I think it is the same reason why people represent their country in a certain sport, or why a mother gives her child a 100% devotion. Passion. I have always had passion for politics for some reason. It is like a calling that I cannot resist and I would not be satisfied if I did not do something to address that calling.
I am lucky to have a wife that understands my passion. My son however is still adjusting to the fact that I am always in Johor. He misses me tremendously and keeps telling my wife that he too wants to work with me in Johor. Sadly, politics is no place for a child. The hours and traveling is brutal for a young toddler and besides he has got kindergarten to attend.
My late mother Hanim Hussein use to discourage me from entering politics because of the corruption, back stabbing, greed and dirt that comes as a package in politics. However, she slowly changed her mind when she saw that I was persistent and I kept holding on to my intentions of why i was entering the political arena.
I still believe in the idealisms and struggles of Dato’ Onn, The Tunku, Tun Razak and Tun Hussein. These leaders before us were in politics purely to serve the people. These days it is quite the opposite but I believe it is not too late to change.
I am sure that many young Malaysians share the same idealisms that I hold on to so dearly. I pray and hope that we do not forget our intentions and not get swayed along the way.
Wednesday, July 9, 2008
An Education System Worthy of Malaysia
I read a book titled “An Education System worthy of Malaysia” about 5 years ago. The author wrote the book using the American education system as a model to make comparison to the Malaysian education system. His book basically concludes by saying that a lot more needs to be done to upgrade our Malaysian education system.
I did not think much of it then but now that I have two kids I am forced to think about the future of my kids and where they should study and go to school. My eldest is three years old and he is currently going to a kindergarten not too far from home. He also goes to music class twice a week and every time he comes back from kindergarten and music class he will be so happy and there will be a glow in his face which says that he has learnt a lot of things and that he really had a good time learning with his friends.
This look and glow from my son was the exact same look that I saw in my nephews face until they went to primary school. The change in system and method of teaching really shocked their system but as time past they learnt to adapt and blend into the system. This is the exact same system which I adapted to when I was a child.
Having said all that, when viewed in the context of our achievements vis-a-vis the other Commonwealth countries, it is heartening to note that our education system ranks very high in key indicators among our peers who share the same legacy, colonial past and system. It is, therefore, crucial that we appreciate the fact that we need not start from scratch. We have to build on these strong fundamentals, adjust where necessary, reform where needed and re-engineer what is not working.
The next step forward I think is to compare ourselves to developed nations where children are thought using the best techniques and methods. There was a research carried out recently by the UN with stated that the problem with Malaysian students is that they lack creativity.
A key method used by developed nations and my son’s kindergarten to make learning more fun and allow the child to be creative in thinking is to use the VAK method. The VAK method, also known as the visual, auditory and kinaesthetic is a method which allows a child to learn in a manner that best suites them. Using the VAK method a teacher will use visual aids, auditory aids and movement to teach making learning much more enjoyable for the child.
Our education system focuses mainly on the auditory aspects and it is usually just a one way conversation. The teacher will speak and the child will only listen and to make things worst they are not allowed to ask questions. It is therefore not a wonder why many kids feel bored at school and memorise facts and figures for the sake of exams. Kids should learn and study because it is fun and meaningful and not just because they have to sit for an exam.
The good news is that my wife and I still have a couple of years to decide on which school to send our son. I would love to hear comments from parents in Malaysia and abroad that are facing the same dilemma as us.
Monday, July 7, 2008
Bar Council Causes Stir Over Hosting Social Contract Forum.
28 June 2008, a social contract forum was held at the Bar Council Kuala Lumpur today. Approximately 300 people attended the forum attracting all races and age groups. The panel members were Dr Mavis Puthucheany, political scientist, Dr Kua Kia Soong, director SUARAM, Dr Farish Noor, political scientist, Tommy Thomas, advocate & solicitor.
For those who attended the forum, they could clearly see that it was not a healthy and open discussion. One could basically describe it as an UMNO bashing session where all panelist were basically pro-opposition. Even the famous Dr Farish who supposedly represented the Malays was a liberal Malay who has clearly forgotten his routes. The panel was one sided and there was no balance in views and opinions. It is disappointing that the Bar Council who preach for justice and healthy discussion only had pro opposition on the panel. This is where I come in to give a differing view and probably a more balanced view.
All four panelist started off by talking about the history of Malaysia. However, the panel was divided in its conclusion. Thommy Thomas and Dr Farish Noor concluded that the social contract should not be scraped as it binds the fabric of this country. It must however be reinvented so that it becomes relevant to 2008 and the years to come.
The underlying message of the forum or the hidden agenda, if you like, was that every Malaysian should have equal rights and we need to re-look at what was agreed 50 years ago.
I have to admit, for the sake of unity I have to agree that the social contract needs to be revisited. Whether the timing is now or later remains debatable. But one has to remember that when one asks the Malays to give up their rights and privileges they should understand that the Malays would naturally be upset for the obvious reasons.
So let us turn the tables just for a moment. During the forum, Dr Kua said that the Chinese Schools and Indian Schools should be maintained for the Chinese race and the Indian race as it is human rights issue and no one should question that. Even if it is true that it is a human rights issue, all I am asking is that can’t you can learn Chinese and the Indian language at a National School?
One could argue that if the Chinese are sincere about racial unity than they should start to act in a sincere manner. Why should they be afraid that the vernacular schools be closed down? As the saying goes, if there is a will there is a way. They can still learn the mother tongue in national schools. How convenient? Let us look at the social contract and lets take out what favors the Malays but let us maintain whatever is convenient to the non- Malays.
My conclusion is that the idealism and the spirit of Malaysian Malaysia can only come true when all races are ready and willing to give up their rights and privileges and not at the expense of any one race.
For those who attended the forum, they could clearly see that it was not a healthy and open discussion. One could basically describe it as an UMNO bashing session where all panelist were basically pro-opposition. Even the famous Dr Farish who supposedly represented the Malays was a liberal Malay who has clearly forgotten his routes. The panel was one sided and there was no balance in views and opinions. It is disappointing that the Bar Council who preach for justice and healthy discussion only had pro opposition on the panel. This is where I come in to give a differing view and probably a more balanced view.
All four panelist started off by talking about the history of Malaysia. However, the panel was divided in its conclusion. Thommy Thomas and Dr Farish Noor concluded that the social contract should not be scraped as it binds the fabric of this country. It must however be reinvented so that it becomes relevant to 2008 and the years to come.
The underlying message of the forum or the hidden agenda, if you like, was that every Malaysian should have equal rights and we need to re-look at what was agreed 50 years ago.
I have to admit, for the sake of unity I have to agree that the social contract needs to be revisited. Whether the timing is now or later remains debatable. But one has to remember that when one asks the Malays to give up their rights and privileges they should understand that the Malays would naturally be upset for the obvious reasons.
So let us turn the tables just for a moment. During the forum, Dr Kua said that the Chinese Schools and Indian Schools should be maintained for the Chinese race and the Indian race as it is human rights issue and no one should question that. Even if it is true that it is a human rights issue, all I am asking is that can’t you can learn Chinese and the Indian language at a National School?
One could argue that if the Chinese are sincere about racial unity than they should start to act in a sincere manner. Why should they be afraid that the vernacular schools be closed down? As the saying goes, if there is a will there is a way. They can still learn the mother tongue in national schools. How convenient? Let us look at the social contract and lets take out what favors the Malays but let us maintain whatever is convenient to the non- Malays.
My conclusion is that the idealism and the spirit of Malaysian Malaysia can only come true when all races are ready and willing to give up their rights and privileges and not at the expense of any one race.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)